On January 31, 1997—fifteen years ago today—Star Wars: Special Edition was released in theaters. Not many people remember this date, but I remember it vividly. I had been looking forward to the rerelease of my favorite movies, with added computer-generated special effects, for months. I poured over every detail I came across in magazines, television, and the web. As a child it seemed they would never come out.
Unfortunately, they did.
My attitude towards the special editions wasn’t overly negative at first: I loved many of the changes. The original Star Wars movies—especially A New Hope—contain many special effects that simply don’t hold up well. That’s the downside to being so innovative, so bleeding edge. Having many of these issues fixed and polished felt good. It felt right.
But there were two major things I didn’t like:
First, there were many errors and issues that weren’t fixed in these original special editions. There were matte paintings, for example, that were still annoyingly off in their perspective. There were spaceship shots that still looked fake. Lightsabers were still the wrong color. Most of these issues were eventually fixed in subsequent editions of the films, but why release a buggy, spotty special edition in theaters? Was there not enough time or money to clean everything up?
The answers lie, perhaps, in the second thing I didn’t like: George Lucas went beyond polishing to adding extra scenes. A computer generated Jabba the Hutt meets with Han Solo in one added scene. It’s flashy and new, but ultimately adds nothing to the experience, ruining the pacing of the film in the process. It was baffling and distracting to see Jabba sliding around like that. Oh, and then there is the “Han shot first” debacle. It is extraordinary how a single second of tweaked footage can completely destroy a beloved character.
The more I thought about these additions—even as a kid—the more I hated them. What I wanted was a cleaned-up version of my favorite movies, but that’s not what I got. Today, the recently released blu-ray editions of Star Wars still retain these changes, and add even more. A quality, high definition release that respects the original vision of these movies may never be released, and it’s one of the most shameful things to happen in the history of film. These three movies deserve much better treatment than they’ve received these past fifteen years, treatment that has been anything but special.